CELPIP, Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading

Gym Membership Dilemma: sample answer

A model answer to this exam-style CELPIP comparing and persuading question, written to a level 10 target. See the question, the full answer and exactly why it works, then try it yourself.

Practice Comparing and Persuading free Read the answer

Task: Comparing and Persuading
Time: 60s to prepare, 60s to speak
Answer length: 152 words, ~68s
Written to: Level 10 target

The question

Situation

Your friend is planning to finally join a gym and wants to choose the best membership plan for both of you. You both need to decide on one plan that suits your fitness goals and budget. Look at the two options below and persuade them to choose one over the other. FitLife Platinum: Monthly: $75, Access: All clubs, 24/7, Classes: Unlimited premium classes (spin, yoga, HIIT), Guest Passes: 2 per month, Contract: 1-year minimum. ActiveZone Flex: Monthly: $50, Access: Single club, peak hours only (6 AM - 9 PM), Classes: Limited standard classes (Zumba, circuit training), Guest Passes: None, Contract: Month-to-month, no commitment.

Task

Sample answer

Hey, after reviewing both gym membership options, I am convinced that the ActiveZone Flex plan is the best choice for us. I know you might like FitLife Platinum for its 24/7 access and premium classes, but let us look at the finances. ActiveZone Flex is more affordable at $50 a month compared to FitLife at $75. That saves us $25 each month, which really adds up over time for healthy groceries. Also, the month-to-month contract with ActiveZone is a huge advantage. FitLife requires a one-year minimum commitment, which could be a burden if our schedules change. ActiveZone allows us to try it out without being locked in, and the peak hours access from 6 AM to 9 PM with standard classes is sufficient for our needs right now. Considering the cost savings and no long-term commitment, ActiveZone Flex offers better value and less risk. Don't you agree it is more practical?

152 words, about 68s spoken

Why it works

What you can measure in this answer, and what CELPIP raters mark.

The right length. 152 words, about 68 seconds at a natural pace: inside the 60-second limit with room to finish calmly.
9 sentences in 68 seconds: complete thoughts at a steady pace, without rushing to fit more in.

How CELPIP marks comparing and persuading

Content & CoherenceLevel 1–12
Enough relevant ideas, organised clearly and supported with detail.
VocabularyLevel 1–12
Words chosen precisely and appropriately for the topic.
ListenabilityLevel 1–12
Rhythm, pronunciation, intonation and few distracting pauses or self-corrections.
Task FulfillmentLevel 1–12
Answers every part, with the right tone and length.

Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading guide

Common questions

How long should a CELPIP Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading answer be?

You get 60 seconds to prepare and up to 60 seconds to speak. At a natural pace that's roughly 110 to 155 words. This sample is 152 words, about 68 seconds spoken.

How is CELPIP Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading scored?

CELPIP marks it on Content & Coherence, Vocabulary, Listenability, Task Fulfillment, each on a Level 1 to 12 scale. Your result for the task comes from these together.

Is this a real CELPIP question?

No. It's an original, exam-style question written to match the official format. Nobody can legally publish real test questions.

Should I memorise this answer?

No. Use it to see the structure, length and linking words that work, then answer in your own words. Memorised answers rarely fit a new question and raters notice.

Where can I practice this question and get a score?

Open it on PrepScroll: record or type your own answer and get an instant estimated score on each CELPIP criterion, with what to fix. It's free to start.

Now try a comparing and persuading question yourself

Speak your answer and get an instant estimated CELPIP level with what to fix. Free to start, nothing to install.

Practice Comparing and Persuading More sample answers